If you know, you know — and Buffalonians definitely know how to get the most out of their order at Imperial Pizza. While the pizza, wings, and subs speak for themselves, there are a few unwritten rules and menu hacks that regulars swear by.
Whether it’s your first visit or your 100th, these top five insider tips will help you order like a pro and level up your Imperial Pizza experience.
1. 🔥 Ask for “Extra Crispy” Wings
Love your wings with a little more crunch? Add a simple phrase to your order:
“Can you make them extra crispy?”
It’s a favorite trick for wing lovers who want that satisfying bite — especially with medium, hot, or garlic parm sauces.
Pro Tip: Pair extra crispy wings with onion rings for a crunchy combo that hits hard.
2. 🍕 Order a Half Pie to Try More Toppings
Want more than just cheese or pepperoni but not ready to commit to a full specialty pie?
Order a half pie with two topping combos – for example, one half Steak & Cheese, the other Reuben.
It’s the best way to try two signature pizzas without wasting food (or blowing your budget).
Hack: Order with a friend and split the pie + an appetizer = instant lunch win.
3. 🧀 Double Up the Cheese (Without Breaking the Bank)
Buffalo-style pizza already comes loaded, but if you’re a cheese fanatic, ask for:
“Extra cheese, light sauce”
It creates that gooey pull every pizza lover dreams of — and balances out the rich, crispy crust without going overboard.
This works especially well on pepperoni and veggie pies.
4. 🌱 Turn the Chicken Finger Sub into a Secret Salad
Trying to eat a little cleaner but still want that flavor?
Order a Chicken Finger Sub, “deconstructed” into a salad.
Just ask:
“Can I get the chicken fingers (grilled or fried) on a tossed salad with your sub toppings?”
Boom — Buffalo salad hack unlocked.
5. 🌙 Visit Late (But Order Ahead)
Imperial’s Main Street location is open until 3:45 a.m., but locals know it gets packed after midnight.
Want that late-night slice or sub without the wait? Order ahead online around 11:30 p.m. and set your pickup for later.
Bonus: Skip the crowd and be out in 5 minutes while everyone else is waiting 20.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Can I customize my pizza order at Imperial Pizza?
A: Yes! You can build your own or request custom half-and-half toppings, light sauce, or extra crispy crust.
Q: What’s the best way to get extra crispy wings?
A: Just ask for them “extra crispy” when placing your order. Works for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
Q: Can I order a salad with chicken fingers instead of a sub?
A: Yes — request a tossed or chef salad with grilled or fried chicken fingers and your preferred toppings.
Q: Is it cheaper to order a half pie instead of a full specialty pizza?
A: Yes — half pies give you the taste of a specialty without the full price. It’s great for trying something new.
Q: What’s the best time to order late-night food from Imperial?
A: For quicker service, order around 11:30 p.m. to midnight, before the post-bar rush. Use the website for pickup or delivery.
Imperial Pizza isn’t just food — it’s a Buffalo tradition with local secrets. Use these hacks and level up your next order like a true Buffalonian.
👉 Test out these tips for yourself by ordering at imperialpizzabuffalo.com