In a city where pizza competition is fierce and loyalty runs deep, Imperial Pizza has built a reputation that speaks for itself. For over 30 years, this South Buffalo institution has been delivering giant slices, crispy wings, and community vibes that locals can’t stop talking about.
From glowing Yelp posts to late-night Twitter shoutouts, we rounded up what real Buffalonians are saying about Imperial Pizza—and why it remains one of the most recommended spots in the city.
⭐ Yelp & Google Reviews: A Snapshot
🔹 “My go-to since high school.”
“Hands down the best pepperoni pizza in Buffalo. That cup-and-char crust with the thick cheese—nothing compares.”
– ★★★★★ Yelp Review
🔹 “Wings that never disappoint.”
“Ordered 50 medium wings for a family party. They were crispy, juicy, and coated just right. You know you’re in Buffalo when wings like this show up.”
– ★★★★★ Google Review
🔹 “The late-night king.”
“Got off work at 2:30 a.m. and Imperial was still open. Giant slice and a sub hit the spot. Lifesaver.”
– ★★★★ Grubhub Customer
🗣️ Reddit & Word of Mouth: Local Buzz
Buffalo Reddit threads are full of pizza debates—but Imperial’s name comes up again and again.
“If you’ve never had a Steak & Cheese pizza from Imperial, do you even live in Buffalo?”
– u/BuffaloSliceLife
“Imperial’s Main Street location saved my Saturday night more than once. Late-night wings, elite subs, and those slices… lethal.”
– u/NightShiftNate
👪 Community Favorite for Generations
It’s not just about the food—Imperial Pizza is part of Buffalo’s identity.
- A go-to for family dinners and birthday parties
- A late-night destination for college students and night owls
- A catering staple for game days and graduations
Imperial’s ability to serve generations of Buffalonians has earned it more than just reviews—it’s earned loyalty.
Why the Reviews Matter
- Builds trust with new customers looking for reliable food spots
- Confirms consistent quality in both dine-in and delivery
- Showcases the wide appeal: from wings to subs, from quick bites to family meals
Online reviews have become word-of-mouth 2.0, and in Buffalo, the word is clear: Imperial is a pizza powerhouse.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is Imperial Pizza’s Google rating?
A: Imperial Pizza consistently holds a 4.4+ star rating on Google across both locations, with thousands of reviews praising quality, portion size, and service.
Q: What do people say about the wings?
A: Reviews often mention crispy texture, great sauce options, and consistent quality. Wing lovers frequently recommend medium and garlic parm.
Q: Are there negative reviews?
A: Like any busy pizzeria, occasional reviews mention long wait times during peak hours—but food quality is rarely criticized.
Q: Is Imperial Pizza good for families?
A: Yes! Reviews highlight family-friendly service, generous portions, and catering options that make it perfect for birthdays and gatherings.
Q: How does Imperial compare to other Buffalo pizza spots?
A: Reviewers often rank Imperial among the top pizza spots in Buffalo, especially for those who love traditional Buffalo-style slices, large portions, and late-night service.
If you’re still wondering where to order your next pie or wings from, take it from the thousands of Buffalonians who already know: Imperial Pizza is a must.
👉 Read more reviews or place your order now at imperialpizzabuffalo.com